The cathelin-like domain (CLD) of cathelicidins is grouped in the same superfamily with cystatins, natural cysteine protease inhibitors, due to their structural similarity. Intriguingly, human hCAP-18/LL37 and pig protegrin-3 (PG3) CLDs exhibit opposite effects against cathepsin L. Here, I evaluated the functional importance of the CLD through identifying whether positive selection has driven adaptive evolution of this domain. As a result, four positively selected sites were detected and three of them are located on a loop region previously recognized as a key determinant of the activating effect of the PG3 CLD. Analysis of amino acid variability of the CLD led to the discovery of a conserved region and three highly variable regions, in which two are subjected to positive selection. Positive selection targeting the variable regions provides a starting point for experimentally establishing a direct link between the observed amino acid changes and functional divergence of the CLD family.